You can hear the song on Spotify here:
I taught Hemingway for seven years as part of an American Literature course, and I never quite knew what to do with him.
That probably sounds strange coming from someone who kept teaching him, but maybe that was part of the attraction. I respected Hemingway more consistently than I enjoyed him. I understood why he mattered. I could teach the iceberg theory, the sparse prose, the dialogue, the code hero, “grace under pressure,” and the enormous influence he had on American writing. But I never particularly loved the cadence of his prose. Sometimes the simplicity felt almost too deliberate to me—an impersonation of simplicity rather than simplicity itself.
Still, Hemingway stayed with me.
Really, that whole Modernist period did. It was one of my favorite stretches of American literature to teach because it was fascinating, dark, occasionally maddening, and unusually honest. The writers who emerged from World War I and lived through the upheavals that followed had good reason to be suspicious of easy optimism. The expatriates were especially interesting to me. They seemed to be looking back at America from a distance, questioning assumptions about progress, prosperity, heroism and the good life that an earlier generation had been more willing to trust.
It made for quite a classroom: Fitzgerald and the beautiful corruption of Gatsby; Faulkner digging through memory, guilt and the past; Steinbeck finding dignity among people who had almost nothing; Pound, brilliant and deeply troubling; and Hemingway, determined to strip away anything that sounded too easy.
They were fun to teach precisely because they weren't particularly fun. They were truthful.
And Hemingway may have been the most complicated of them for me.
There is a lot about the Hemingway persona that invites admiration. He was adventurous, physically courageous and seemingly determined to experience life at full volume. War, hunting, fishing, bullfighting, boxing, travel—there is almost a cult of difficulty surrounding him. If life wasn't hard enough on its own, Hemingway seemed willing to go looking for places where it could become harder.
But I was always a little suspicious of that, too.
How much was Hemingway, and how much was Hemingway playing Hemingway?
The public figure became almost as famous as the writer: Papa Hemingway, the tough guy, the drinker, the sportsman, the war correspondent, the man who had been there and done that. Was the mythology simply an extension of the man, or did the man eventually become trapped inside the mythology? Did readers love the writing, or did some of them love the sensational life surrounding the writer? I don't know. I'm not sure anyone can completely know.
There was an evasiveness about Hemingway that bothered me as much as it fascinated me. He could be emotionally manipulative while appearing emotionally detached. He could leave enormous things unsaid and somehow make the silence carry more weight than an explanation would have.
Jake Barnes's final response to Brett in The Sun Also Rises has always haunted me: “Isn't it pretty to think so?”
There is an entire life inside that sentence—a life that will never happen.
That is Hemingway at his best for me. I may resist the style, but I can't dismiss what is underneath it.
And that tension eventually found its way into “Withstood the Wind.”
The obvious Hemingway reference in the song comes from A Farewell to Arms: “The world breaks every one and afterward many are strong at the broken places.”
It is one of those Hemingway lines that has escaped the novel and become almost inspirational. Put by itself, it is beautiful. I believe there is truth in it. Life breaks us, and sometimes healing creates a kind of strength that wasn't there before. The scar isn't merely evidence of the wound; it can also be evidence of healing.
But Hemingway doesn't stop there.
The rest of that passage is considerably darker. Life also kills the very good, the very gentle and the very brave. And if you are none of those things, Hemingway says, you can be sure it will kill you too; there simply won't be any special hurry.
That isn't exactly something you put on a motivational poster.
And yet I appreciate the honesty of it.
The world does break people. Being brave doesn't exempt you. Neither does being good. Sometimes we heal beautifully at the broken places, and sometimes we don't. Sometimes the next wind comes before the last wound has completely healed.
That is where the Hemingway hero becomes fascinating to me.
He stands.
He maintains the code. He does the job. His hands may tremble, but he behaves with courage anyway. He accepts that he cannot control the world, so he controls the manner in which he meets it. Hemingway called that kind of courage “grace under pressure,” and there is something undeniably admirable about it.
But after years of teaching those characters, I was left with a question I never completely resolved:
Is standing enough?
Is the Hemingway hero actually a hero, or is he simply an existential man who stands because standing is the only meaningful act left to him? If there is no larger purpose to the suffering, no redemption beyond endurance, then what has he accomplished when he withstands the wind?
I don't ask that as a criticism so much as an honest question. Hemingway himself makes it harder because the mythology of toughness eventually collides with a life that ended sadly. I don't want to use the end of his life to explain the man or judge him. Human beings are more complicated than that. But neither can I read all that language about courage, breaking, endurance and standing without feeling the weight of what we know came later.
That tension became the man in the song.
At first we see the Hemingway hero almost exactly as we expect him:
Through the dusk, the hero stands,
Grace under pressure, trembling hands.
But I didn't want to leave him there.
I wanted to meet him after everyone else had gone home.
So later we find him in a room at two in the morning:
Medals rest beside the bed,
But ghosts still speak of things unsaid.
For me, that is where “Withstood the Wind” really begins.
The medal tells the public story. The room tells the private one.
He stood when he was supposed to stand. He did something difficult. People may even have called him courageous. But now there is no crowd, no battle and no one watching. The medal still shines, but the scar still aches.
Scars don't shine in silver light—
They ache the most when it's this quiet.
So what now?
I don't think the answer is pretending that strong people don't break. In fact, the chorus deliberately admits the opposite:
Let the wind come—we won't bow.
It may break us—not us now.
That phrase matters to me: it may break us.
This isn't a song about invincibility. I don't believe in that kind of strength anymore, if I ever did. The scar itself proves we were vulnerable. We were hurt. Something happened that left a mark.
But we're here.
And that brings me to the bridge:
I almost laid my purpose down,
Almost let the silence drown.
But something in me still won't bend—
A quiet voice that says, “Stand.”
Maybe the most important word there isn't stand.
Maybe it's purpose.
That's where I think I finally part company with the Hemingway hero—or at least where my questions about him become my own. I admire the man who can stand in the wind. I admire grace under pressure. I admire courage that doesn't need an audience.
I'm just not convinced that standing, by itself, is enough.
I need there to be a reason to stand.
And perhaps that is why, after seven years of teaching Hemingway, after admiring him and distrusting him, enjoying him and arguing with him, he somehow ended up in one of my songs.
I still haven't settled the argument.
Maybe I don't need to.
The wind comes. The world breaks all of us eventually. Some wounds heal stronger. Some continue to ache at two in the morning. Courage doesn't mean pretending otherwise.
Sometimes courage is considerably less dramatic.
Sometimes there is no safari, no battlefield, no great fish on the line, no one watching to see what you will do.
Sometimes there is only a quiet room, a scar, a reason you haven't completely surrendered, and a voice barely loud enough to hear.
Stand.
And for tonight, maybe that's enough.
No comments:
Post a Comment